A crowd-sourced toplist with the best hipster hotels in Fort Myers Beach. Edited by Ella Norberg.
This is a toplist with the best hipster hotels in Fort Myers Beach, USA. You can help to make this list better by voting for your favourite places!
Great experience. The location is extremely convenient to the beach and shops. The free shuttle runs right by the hotel which makes getting around a little easier. Be aware that the shuttle is seasonal but was operating while we were here.
Location is great! Quiet but yet close to the strip for shopping, beach and fun! There a few sitting areas outside which is nice for new scenery. Rooms were very clean and accommodating however the wifi didn't work in our room. Worked outside just fine. We met some great people. We would definitely stay here again and look forward to it!!
Absolutely love this place! If you’re looking for a quiet place to stay this isn’t it but everything else was superb! Staff and prices are solid and the view and access to the beach is great! I’m gonna name drop one of the bartenders Beth only because she’s that laid back very personable kind oh and she loves to make shots. ;) Thanks to all of Lani Kai’s staff for making my visit successful and lots of fun!
Relaxing, food was real good, drinks were great. Staff friendly. Beach is beautiful & huge. Rooms were spotless. It's away from times square but you can drive there or take trolley about 10-15 min away. And their pool is very nice & heated. Definitely will stay here again.
Covid has REALLY put a damper on travel these days. After having several vacations either cancelled by resorts or by ourselves... we landed at Cottages of Paradise Point. Our group consisted of 3 families. Between the 3 families we had children ranging in ages of 1 year to 12 years of age. We occupied the Dolphin and Gulf Cottages. We felt as though we had our own private beach. Nestled in a traffic free and peaceful portion of the island. But, only a 10 minute (walking) commute from all the happening places to eat. We were all super impressed by the amenities offered, cleanliness and stellar service. You truly feel as though you are a guest and not a customer. We are already working on our next trip and we can't wait to stay at Cottages of Paradise Point again!
Best Onion Rings on the island. Great water views of the bay. Good dockage and helpful people if you arrive by boat.
Really nice place. Pretty quiet but close to everything. Was nice having a full fridge and a stove. Having access to grilles and bikes and umbrellas was a nice plus.
The bed was just ok and the bathroom sink could use replacing. We had some tiny ants in the kitchen. Nothing to keep us from returning here again though. Relaxing few days for sure.
We stayed at the Mango Street Inn for just a few nights but left wishing we stayed longer! Dan and Tree were such great hosts, we felt right at home the moment we got there. The room was very clean and had everything we needed, the beach was just across the street, and there were a few good restaurants and bars within walking distance. The atmosphere overall was very welcoming and friendly! Dan and Tree really go above and beyond to make sure you have everything you need. I would highly recommend this unique place to anyone...we will definitely be coming back!
Stayed right on the beach. Amazing view and so quiet.
Great laid back place. If you're looking for a simple place within walking distance of the beach without a lot of frills, this place is for you. It's a little dated, but clean. Exactly what we were looking for.
Cute rooms, very nice common areas on the 2nd and 3rd floors. Some maintenance needed in our suite. I have messaged the hotel with that info so hopefully they take care of it. The carpets were very dirty in the room and I feel they are taking the COVID thing way to far. There were 4 of us in 1 suite with 1 bathroom so we used the restrooms in the common area frequently, but woke up one morning (out of 2) to find they had been locked some time during the night. One person using the potty and 3 others waiting to get in. Also, they have stopped providing coffee period, even in the rooms/suites. I can see not having it in common areas but in the privacy of our rooms? Front desk hours are extremely limited (good luck). Beds and pillows were very comfy. I do not usually sleep well in hotels, but slept better at this hotel than any I can remember.
Enjoyed our stay. Liked availability to breakfast, lunch, and dinner all at 1 location. Loved the Tikki Bar and it's atmosphere. Rooms were nice and clean. First time staying there and would recommend to friends and family.
My husband and I arrived late Sunday night and were pleasantly surprised that we were upgraded to a much larger room for no extra charge. Almost too much room for just the two of us, but definitely loved it. Did I mention there is a Pin Ball machine in our room? Everyone here has been very friendly and helpful. The rooms are nice and decent. Could use a bit of updating on certain things, but nothing that wouldn’t stop me from coming back again or recommending to others.
The beach is literally only a block away and it’s beautiful. Sun Deck and Inn does provide chairs and a few things, but we decided just to rent some lounge chairs and umbrella at the beach. Lots of bars, restaurants and Fort Myers Beach stores near by.
Beautiful beach! nice and clean and open
This is my family's favorite place to stay for vacation. The facility and pool are always clean, and has private access to the beach.
We had a wonderful time at the Tiki and can’t wait to come back! Very clean rooms, a very kind staff that goes above and beyond, and a great location! The kitchen was fully equipped with everything we needed to eat in for 5 days, complete with a gas grille in the courtyard! The tiki bar and free paddle boards were an awesome added bonus! They take great care in making sure you are comfortable and have a fun and relaxing time. It’s within walking distance to all the tourist attractions, but far enough away that you can also just “chill” if that’s not what you’re looking for. We really enjoyed our
getaway and definitely recommend!!
On the beach, quaint resort.
Great place to relax on the beach. I enjoy fishing, swimming, and the attractions. Lots of great local restaurants. And its not super expensive there even offering an extra week deal for anyone who books for the summer at a discounted rate so you get two weeks for less than the price of one.
love it. except this year weather was bad. still love it. cant wait for next year.
The Neptune is a very clean and family friendly resort in a great location. My family's first time to Fort Myers and stayed 5 days. Front staff, Daylin and Isabel were super helpful with places to eat and things to do. Housekeeping and pool area clean with places to grill. Rooms were good size and not run down.
Show
map
I do my best to keep this list very up to date. It was last edited in March 2025. If you know of a hipster hotel that should be on the list, let me know. Click here to contact me. Thanks!
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+
10+